Which Dog Collar Should I Get?

Shopping for a pet collar can be an overwhelming experience as they come in different styles and materials. Before shopping, it is important to determine the purpose of your pet collar (lead). Is it for training, an identification tag, or a style statement?

Here is a simple breakdown of the different types of collars on the market:

Types of Dog Collars

There are several types of dog collars on the market, each with its advantages and disadvantages. The most common types are buckle collars, slip collars (choke chains), and martingale collars (limited-slip). Each type has a specific use and should be chosen based on your dog’s personality and needs.

Buckle Collars

Buckle collars are widely considered the most traditional, classic type of dog or cat collars. A buckle collar is very versatile and can be used on almost any breed. These collars come in many different colors, materials, and styles. They can also be found with special designs such as rhinestones if your dog is accustomed to wearing bling (this usually isn’t recommended).


  • They are easy to install, adjust to fit many dogs, and come in many different colors, styles, and materials.
  • Buckle collars have a removable tag holder, making it possible to attach your dog’s license. Some buckle collars can also be engraved with an identification number for added security.
  • They are versatile, affordable, and great for both small and large breeds.
  • Buckle collars are much easier to put on your dog than a pinch or prong-style collars.
  • Comes in different types of closure systems including Velcro and clips.


  • Buckle collars can break or come undone if snagged on something, and do not offer the same protection that prong or choke collars provide.
  • They also do not offer the same level of choking protection as prong or slip-style collars.
  • Buckle collars can slip off, and they will come undone if snagged on an object.
  • Metal prongs or large buckles can be uncomfortable when rubbing against your dog’s skin.

Slip Collars

Many dog owners consider slip collars the best choice for their pets. If you have a dog that is constantly slipping out of its collar, then this type of collar should be your first choice for them; because it does not require any buckles or clips to attach it to your pet’s neck. Slip collars are also called choke chains because they have a loop that tightens around the neck when you pull on them, then it loosens when not being tugged on the leash.


  • These are great for training dogs who pull excessively when walking on a leash.
  • Great for correcting misbehaviors.
  • When used properly, the dog will not be choked.
  • Slip collars are less likely to break or come undone compared to buckle collars.


  • Slip collars can be difficult to use and may be too tight or too loose on larger and smaller dogs.
  • They can be dangerous if used incorrectly and may cause choking or other injuries.
  • Slip collars are not as adjustable as buckle collars and may not fit all dogs.
  • They can be expensive compared to other types of collars.
  • Slip collars may not be as durable as other types of collars and may break with heavy use.

Martingale Collars

Martingale (limited-slip) collars have gained popularity over the past few years due to their effectiveness in controlling large, strong dogs that pull on their leashes. The design of the collar is somewhat similar to regular choke chains; however, they do not close completely like regular choke chains. When your dog attempts to pull forward while wearing this type of collar, you will notice that he will be unable to get his head out of the loop formed by the slack in the leash. This prevents your dog from slipping out of his collar and keeps him from pulling or straining against the leash.


  • Martingale collars are more secure than traditional dog collars, which means that they are less likely to slip off or choke the dog.
  • Adjustable tightness allows for more control over how tightly it pulls on their necks to prevent injury.
  • Prevents dogs from backing out of their collars, reducing pressure if they pull hard enough.
  • Usually lasts longer than buckle collars.


  • If the wrong size is purchased, this collar can become useless since too much space is available allowing dogs to back out easily
  • They can be uncomfortable for some dogs.
  • These collars may not be suitable for very small or very large dogs.

So, Which Dog Collar Should I Get?

To answer this question, focus on your pet’s personality and the needs for your Pet collar? Is it for control, safety, training, or simply an accessory? Buckle collars have the largest variety of styles and materials if looks and ease of use are what you are going for. Slip/Choke collars are great for ultimate control and behavioral corrections, but it needs to be used carefully to prevent choking hazards. Martingale seems to be a great hybrid solution of control and comfort as you can adjust the tightness of the choke when training your pet.